LeBron James, northeast Ohio’s prodigal son, has returned to the fold! We’re celebrating the Chosen One’s second stint with the Cavs the only way we know how: with ice cream.

When you step into any shop this weekend, consider ordering what we basketball fans here at Jeni’s are enjoying right this very moment—the Prodigal Sundae:

Salty Caramel ice cream: Because we really were salty about you leaving.

Honey Butterscotch Sauce: Because, LeBron ol’ chum, we’re letting bygones be bygones.

Salty Graham Gravel: Because the road we take to come home isn’t always smooth, is it?

Whooped cream: Because whoopee! We can’t wait for the 2014-15 season to begin!