Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Guaranteed frozen delivery

Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
Nationwide delivery

We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
Instagram-worthy unboxing

Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.810219 / 5 from 137 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Savannah Buttermint ice cream, inspired by classic pillow mint candies, offers a minty and buttery flavor with white chocolate flecks for creaminess. Customers highly praise its flavor and subtlety, and appreciate the fast shipping and excellent customer service.

Summary topics

Shipping: 6%
Mint Flavor: 16%
Overall Flavor: 47%
Buttermint Experience: 10%

Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","gift","order","mint","chocolate","texture","ice cream","crunch","customer service","goodness","buttermint","treat","dessert","jeni","perfection","jelly donut","cream","pint","first time","cake","chocolate flakes"].

Review highlights

"I love mint and this mint with the strong butter flavor is amazing and potentially addictive!" — John R.
"I love butter mints and the first taste proved that this may be my favorite mint ice cream of all times!!" — Stephanie C.
"Loved the lite mint taste and the white chocolate pieces!" — Cheryl B.

Reviews

Buttermint

"Bring it to stores year round!!!"

— Jana T. (5/5)

All time favorite

"My 5 year old daughter dislikes all things sweet. Candy, juice, cookies, cakes, she won't touch them. But one day I let her taste this and she is in LOVE! I have offered her other ice cream flavors, other brands and she says they are disgusting. But her Savannah Buttermint can do no wrong. Everyone I know, family, friends, coworkers knows she loves her Jeni's Savannah Buttermint!"

— LaDonna (5/5)

Jeni's Six Pack

"Savannah Buttermint was the star of the show. Rich, creamy and very refreshing. Kudos for capturing the flavor of these classic mints. The two new Bridgerton varieties were also very good. Although, I'll probably need many more tastings before rendering my final verdict."

— Joseph L. (5/5)

Savannah Buttermint

"My number 2 pick of all of them. Tastes just like a buttermint. . . so yummy!"

— Peg C. (5/5)

Too bland.

"Too bland. Mint flavor is so excessively strong that it has no nuanced complexity that I expect from Jeni's ice cream. The texture is very unique, but not quite in a pleasant way."

— Jon (3/5)

Love your stuff!

"Love so many of your ice creams but how can you name one after Savannah and not even have a store here! Please fix by opening up in Savannah!!"

— A r. (5/5)

Next level minty

"A new fav!! So refreshing and excellent taste!"

— Otira J. (5/5)

Just Like The After Dinner Mints

"On special occasions, we would go to the clubhouse for dinner. My favorite part was when the waitstaff would hand me extra butter mints and wink. I love this ice cream reminiscent of those mints"

— Kasey P. (5/5)

Favvvv

"Truly my favorite. Can’t get enough."

— Shelby S. (5/5)

Great customer service!

"Jeni's customer service is extraordinarily good! We had a hiccup with the delivery service (not Jeni's fault) but the Jeni's folks figured it all out. And the ice cream is still fabulous."

— Krista F. (5/5)