Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.913242 / 5 from 219 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

The Best Sellers Collection by Jeni's Ice Cream is highly recommended by customers for its exceptional customer service, delicious flavors, and reliable shipping. The collection is a favorite among shoppers, and the gift packaging is also praised. However, there are mixed opinions about reordering.

Summary topics

  • Customer Service (8%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the exceptional and great customer service provided by Jeni's Ice Cream.
  • Product Popularity (6%): It was observed by customers that the product was a huge hit, with multiple reviews expressing this opinion.
  • Gift Idea (34%): Many customers stated that the gift was perfect, great, and wonderful, making it the most common opinion.
  • Packaging Quality (4%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the great packaging of the product, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
  • Flavor Satisfaction (20%): Many customers expressed satisfaction with the flavor, describing it as delicious, amazing, wonderful, and bold.

Review topics: [flavor, quality, delivery, order, box, packaging, selection, service, gift, customer service, chocolate, ice cream, treat, texture, mix, hit, idea, collection, surprise, friend, christmas, jeni, jeni’s, staff, mom, experience, choice, recipients, birthday, cream].

Review highlights

  • "Delicious flavors, excellent presentation and efficient customer service"Mary M.
  • "Amazing: service, flavor, and variety."Nancy M.
  • "Everyone loved the unique variety and bold flavors."Eric H.

Reviews

Wrong message

"The ice cream was great and much appreciated! Unfortunately, the note that was left with the package was from someone else and must have gotten mixed up with another delivery."

Kathryn K. (4/5)

Simply the Best

"Thank you for replacing the lost shipment so quickly and deliciously 🤗"

Mark F. (5/5)

I love my mom and my mom loves this ice cream

"I sent my mom the Best Sellers Collection for Mother's Day, and she was SO happy. She's quite picky about ice cream and usually think it's too sweet or not sweet enough, or too thick or not creamy enough, or needs "something. " But she only had gushing things to say about every flavor in this combo! My dad was also happy because my mom was happy, and because she usually doesn't buy ice cream. Thanks Jeni's for a hugely successful Mother's Day gift!"

David M. (5/5)

administrative assistant

"Our gifts have been received with rave reviews."

kim h. (5/5)

Awesomeness

"I have sent these 5 pack to friends for years. At least 20 times and have nothing but glowing reviews. My friends have also sent the 5 pack to their friends Bottom line is the ice cream is amazing After all the gifts i think I need to send a 5 pack to myself"

Kathleen H. (5/5)

Great Ice Cream, Creative Flavors!

"I ordered the Best Sellers Collection and all were a delight. Ordering was easy and the packaging was excellent - there was still some of the dry ice left. The Ice Cream was still totally frozen! I've ordered another set of random picks and am anxiously waiting for them to arrive."

Randall S. (5/5)

Best Gift ever!

"Received this as a gift after a surgery! Every flavor was incredible!"

Lisa l. (5/5)

Outstanding!!

"Beni’s is my favorite brand of ice cream, by far. I love to surprise friends with a big batch at Christmas. Keep it coming!"

George L. (5/5)

Best Seller Collection

"I gave the ice cream as a holiday gift and everyone loved getting this unique gift!"

Anne P. (5/5)

5 pack

"Tasty and delicious"

John D. (5/5)

Q&A