• Pint of Jeni's Salty Caramel ice cream, an orange pint with a spoon topped with pale scoops

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8388276 / 5 from 273 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Jeni's Salty Caramel ice cream, known for its unique flavor and nutty quality, has been a hit since 1996. Customers praise its delicious caramel, perfect flavor, and the intention to order again. The gift aspect is also highly appreciated.

Summary topics

  • Caramel Quality (12%): It was noted by customers that the Salty Caramel is delicious and has a unique flavor.
  • Flavor Appreciation (23%): A significant amount of customers expressed appreciation for the flavor, describing it as perfect, fabulous, and their all-time favorite.
  • Product Popularity (5%): It was noted by customers that the product is a big hit, which is a very common opinion.
  • Repeat Order Intention (4%): It was highlighted by customers that they will definitely order again with Jeni's, expressing their intention to order again.
  • Gift Appreciation (14%): Customers keep praising the gift, describing it as perfect, great, wonderful, and amazing.

Review topics: ["flavor","delivery","packaging","order","gift","customer service","texture","service","blend","selection","favorite","ice cream","chocolate","goodness","treat","caramel","hit","salt","jeni","pint","balance","idea","surprise","collection","notes","brand","five candy bar","recipients","cream","ribbons"].

Review highlights

  • "Salty Caramel is my favorite flavor: it's the perfect balance of not-too-sweet with just enough salt." — Claudia
  • "The flavor is truly amazing and fresh and crisp tasting." — Patty M.
  • "I contacted Jeni's and they made it right immediately by sending out a new order that arrived in good, frozen condition." — Sherry C.

Reviews

Best of the best 👌

"Not bad, gona try a new one with this order, but so far "High Five Candy Bar" is the best. Love love love !"

— Carole S. (3/5)

#1 Salted Caramel Ice Cream

"As a late Gen X guy, I proudly take up the mantel of "Salted Caramel is my generation's Werther's Original". That being said, this is easily the best salted caramel ice cream I've tasted, and I've had a ton. The salt level is perfect, the cream level is exquisite, and the caramel is at just the right note. Highly impressive- you can taste the craftsmanship."

— Josh A. (5/5)

Love Jenni’s

"We loved this flavor and creaminess!!!!"

— Pamela C. (5/5)

Best Ice cream ever

"This was the best ice cream I have ever tasted."

— Daryl P. (5/5)

I love salt, but. . .

"I love salt and salty-sweet desserts, but the balance wasn't there for me. I think this could have been better (for me) if there was a consistent thick ribbon of sweet caramel OR the ice cream was standard caramel with the ribbon being the salty caramel. The problem I am having is that the salt is overpowering the delightful caramel flavor. (Also, I tried a little of this with the Blackout Chocolate Cake and somehow they canceled each other out?????)"

— Kari D. (3/5)

All good

"A great caramel"

— Nomee A. (5/5)

Love!

"Perfect balance of salty sweet!"

— Raquel A. (5/5)

This one goes out to the true believers

"We did it guys. We made it through the drought. I came to this review thread roughly a year ago, at my lowest point: the moment I really started thinking we’d never taste this salty, sweet, smooth buttery caramel ice cream EVER AGAIN. “Discontinued!” proclaimed the Reddit threads. I couldn’t fathom that this flavor was gone, and yet it was nowhere to be found. But your mutual pain, your pleas to that cruel mistress, Jeni, to stop withholding the BEST ICE CREAM I WILL EVER TASTE… that comforted me. I was bereft, but I wasn’t alone. And more importantly, it made me believe that no business would permanently cancel a product that was clearly driving potential customers to desperation. No business would could ignore the people exposing their deepest, most vulnerable needs on a public review thread on the off chance that someone in power would read it, and tell Jeni. Which brings me to this moment: it’s my 8th wedding anniversary, and the 2 pints my husband finally found in a Whole Foods are the best 2 gifts he’s given me for any occasion. He knows it, I know, and Jeni should too."

— Bailey (5/5)

Good

"Good"

— Kim W. (4/5)

she's back!

"The disappointment of Salty Caramel being gone was deep. I'm glad it's back on the menu, it's such a great flavor and pairs well with other ice creams."

— Emily C. (5/5)

Q&A