Skip to content

NEW! Summer flavors just dropped. 

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.4885497 / 5 from 131 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Banana Cream Pudding offers a delightful combination of airy cream, dense pudding, and real bananas, anchored by soft wafer cookies. Customers appreciate the excellent texture and great flavor, though opinions on the banana flavor are mixed. Shipping is reported to be excellent with great packaging and fast delivery. Jeni's version of the pudding is particularly praised for its taste and quality.

Summary topics

  • Banana Flavor: 8%
  • Shipping Experience: 6%
  • Product Texture: 8%
  • Product Flavor: 49%
  • Jeni's Banana Pudding: 8%

Review topics: [flavor, gift, texture, order, delivery, treat, customer service, ice cream, packaging, banana, jeni, coconut, banana pudding, dairy, cream, option, daughter, pie, jeni’s, dessert, biscuits].

Review highlights

  • "The coconut gives it a nice bright flavor as well."Keith A.
  • "Great flavor, wonderful texture."Kurt R.
  • "Incredible delicious and refreshing combination of flavors."Jeff G.

Reviews

Only the world's best ice cream

"Excellent customer service when I needed it. The ice cream is so good that I swear angels sing when you taste it. Sweet cream biscuits and peach jam is the hit of the summer."

Lynne S. (5/5)

Phenomenal

"This is by far the best flavor of Jeni's ice cream I've ever had! And in the top 5 of best ice cream I've ever had in my life! So creamy and rich Simply a perfect replication of banana pudding in ice cream form. And SO APPRECIATE that you made the vanilla wafers GF."

Nickie (5/5)

Banana criteria

"Delish just give it more banana. Love Clementine's banana cake and Wright's hummingbird cake. Trader Joe's banana has an edge."

Carol O. (4/5)

Not your average Banana pudding

"Everything but the coconut. I love it though don’t get me wrong! But some bites the coconut was a little over powering."

Hannah R. (4/5)

Jeni’s Banana Cream Pudding

"Delectable! Gf/df which makes it easier for me to digest. The taste is so deliciously good with the right amount of bananas. I highly recommend."

Linda J. (5/5)

Yum

"I saw this unique flavor and it tastes as good as it sounds and was exactly what I was craving. Creamy and delicious. I am not a dairy free diet person but I LIKE cutting back dairy when I can, especially when it tastes as good if not better than regular dairy ice cream."

Mitzi (5/5)

Banana pudding

"Coconut cream worked super well with the banana"

Julia l. (4/5)

Dairy free!

"Very good for a dairy free option"

ROBIN T. (5/5)

Great Ice Cream

"I just tried it and it has a great flavor, very smooth"

James N. (5/5)

Banana pudding

"This was my second favorite, but would definitely buy again"

Stacey J. (5/5)

Q&A