Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.
Overall rating: 4.759259 / 5 from 54 reviews.
Bay Leaf Cheesecake offers a unique and delicious flavor profile, combining the traditional use of bay leaves with creamy ice cream. The herbal notes are light and may be subtle, while the ice cream itself is smooth, creamy, and slightly spiced. This product brings a refreshing twist to traditional cheesecake flavors.
Review topics: ["flavor","delivery","gift","order","combo","treat","favorite","ice cream","notes","swirl","hint","combination","surprise","5 stars","crust","amount","cheesecake"].
"I treated myself to a six pint package of Jeni’s for my birthday. This gave me a chance to try some new flavors, and one of those was Bay Leaf Cheesecake. I hadn’t anticipated finding a new favorite! The smooth cheesecake ice cream has an earthy hint similar to nutmeg, and was absolutely delicious! The graham swirl was thick and rich, and did not disappoint. This will definitely be ordered again…and again, and again!"
"Jeni’s Bay Leaf Cheesecake has absolutely no business being this good. Bay leaf is the ingredient whose entire career consists of being politely removed from soup, yet here it is, headlining an ice cream. The cheesecake is rich, tangy, and decadent, while the bay leaf strolls in wearing a tiny beret, whispering, “I’m complex. ” Against all logic, the two become the dessert equivalent of an unlikely buddy comedy. I came for cheesecake and left questioning why I’ve underestimated a leaf for my entire life."
"I was hesitant to order but I’m glad I did! This flavor combination works and would have never thought I’d eat bay leaf in ice cream. Nice work Jeni!"
"The title is the only word I have for this flavor!!!"
"There was an issue with my order and it was never delivered. When I contacted Jeni's I received an immediate response with 2 options: Cancel the order and get a full refund or have another order sent out immediately. I chose the second option and it was taken care of immediately. No forms, no process, no questions, no delays. It was just done with a very nice apology and a thank you for choosing Jeni's. The order arrived 2 days later! You don't see customer service issues handled like this anymore. The person I dealt with was outstanding in every possible way. Thank you Jeni's for making it so easy to do business with you. I am a customer for life!!!!"
"Never stop making this! I’m an adventurous eater and didn’t see this combination as being that extreme and thought it would be pretty subtle. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the depth of this herbaceous salty sweet treat. Before my first bite I wouldn’t have known that I would experience the joy of tasting something unlike I’ve never bet tasted before and be so delicious. I also enjoyed learning the history of the flavor on the back and something old but new again. Please open a store on the east coast and thank you for making amazing ice cream."
"This is an unexpected surprise- smooth, flavorful and delicious ice cream. I didn’t see this coming - we bought because it was so unique and I’d keep that on my always list."
"Simply the best ice cream we have ever had. The variety of flavors break the dull vanilla, chocolate etc. mold and are at first interesting and then the flavor hits - and WOW! We were introduced to Jeni's via a gift. We hold them in much greater esteem."
"Love this!"
"First, let me say that I LOVE Jeni's ice cream. I ordered it to Washington state for my birthday. It came frozen and, as always, delicious! By far my favorite flavor was the Blackout Chocolate Cake. Very rich and chocolatey. My second favorite was the Earl Grey Creme Brulee. The texture and flavor combos were incredible. We also really enjoyed the Powdered Jelly Donut (delicious raspberry swirl) and the Buttercream Birthday Cake (exactly what it sounds like, lots of cake and sprinkles). The biggest surprise was Bayleaf Cheesecake, which many of my friends guessed was churro or horchata during a blind taste test! I will say, I would not buy Sweet Cream Biscuits and Peach Jam again. Even though it's made with peach puree, the peach somehow tasted syrupy. It was also a bit salty for me. Thank you Jeni's!"
Guaranteed frozen delivery. Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
Free shipping in the contiguous U.S. No matter how many pints you order.
Instagram-worthy unboxing. Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.
LOCAL DELIVERY
SCOOP SHOPS
GROCERY LOCATOR