Name: Bay Leaf Cheesecake
Brand: Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
SKU: 1111
Price: 17.0 USD
Availability: InStock

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Guaranteed frozen delivery

Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
Nationwide delivery

We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
Instagram-worthy unboxing

Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7234044 / 5 from 47 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Bay Leaf Cheesecake offers a unique and delicious flavor profile, combining the traditional use of bay leaves with creamy ice cream. The herbal notes are light and may be subtle, while the ice cream itself is smooth, creamy, and slightly spiced. This product brings a refreshing twist to traditional cheesecake flavors.

Summary topics

Flavor Profile: 60%
Ice Cream Texture: 17%

Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","gift","order","combo","favorite","ice cream","notes","5 stars","crust","swirl","amount"].

Review highlights

"The slightly savory taste was so lovely with the creaminess and subtle crust swirls." — A W.
"Such an interesting and delicious set of flavors." — Maryann H.
"Our friends loved the ice cream as well." — Denise S.

Reviews

genius combo

"Never stop making this! I’m an adventurous eater and didn’t see this combination as being that extreme and thought it would be pretty subtle. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the depth of this herbaceous salty sweet treat. Before my first bite I wouldn’t have known that I would experience the joy of tasting something unlike I’ve never bet tasted before and be so delicious. I also enjoyed learning the history of the flavor on the back and something old but new again. Please open a store on the east coast and thank you for making amazing ice cream."

— Sarina M. (5/5)

Best and Most Interesting and Most Luscious Ice Cream Flavors

"Simply the best ice cream we have ever had. The variety of flavors break the dull vanilla, chocolate etc. mold and are at first interesting and then the flavor hits - and WOW! We were introduced to Jeni's via a gift. We hold them in much greater esteem."

— James D. (5/5)

I love Jeni's!

"First, let me say that I LOVE Jeni's ice cream. I ordered it to Washington state for my birthday. It came frozen and, as always, delicious! By far my favorite flavor was the Blackout Chocolate Cake. Very rich and chocolatey. My second favorite was the Earl Grey Creme Brulee. The texture and flavor combos were incredible. We also really enjoyed the Powdered Jelly Donut (delicious raspberry swirl) and the Buttercream Birthday Cake (exactly what it sounds like, lots of cake and sprinkles). The biggest surprise was Bayleaf Cheesecake, which many of my friends guessed was churro or horchata during a blind taste test! I will say, I would not buy Sweet Cream Biscuits and Peach Jam again. Even though it's made with peach puree, the peach somehow tasted syrupy. It was also a bit salty for me. Thank you Jeni's!"

— Taylor M. (4/5)

Bay Leaf Cheescake

"Very rich and the flavor is GREAT. the cake pieces are a treat and mix in very well."

— Bernard B. (4/5)

-

"Phenomenal and super unique. I’d get this one again."

— Ben R. (5/5)

Worth trying

"I typically avoid cheesecake ice creams but I was curious about the bay leaf. The bay leaf is a great spin. It tastes like vanilla with depth and a hint of pine notes. I gave it 4/5 stars because while it does taste good, I can't eat a lot of it."

— Brittany D. (4/5)

Surprised!

"We were really surprised by how much we LOVED this ice cream. It’s now a forever favorite!"

— Nicole K. (5/5)

It's pretty good but earl grey is still my favorite

"Like the title says"

— Allison H. (4/5)

Ice Cream review and other

"Ah. . . . my favorite ice cream. . . a little pricey for me but you get what you pay for and I am definitely worth it. Loved the credit I received from my first order. . . then I was able to spin and won a reward to shop at a local store. . . but alas there are none in Nebraska I can use the credit for. . . . Just ordered a second shipment and am anxious. . . Love Jeni's!. . Savanah Buttermint is my favorite :)"

— Peg C. (5/5)