• Pint of Jeni's Boston Cream Pie ice cream, a pale yellow pint topped with chocolate-swirled scoops
  • Close-up texture of Boston Cream Pie ice cream with chocolate cake pieces and custard swirl

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.642857 / 5 from 140 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Boston Cream Pie from Jeni is celebrated for its rich history and delightful combination of chocolate and custard. The flavor is highly praised, and the texture and base of the cake are also well-liked. However, opinions on the pint size are mixed.

Summary topics

  • Boston Cream Pie Flavor (9%): Customers keep praising the Boston Cream Pie flavor, describing it as perfectly delicious and a hit with guests.
  • Cake Texture (5%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the great smooth texture and perfect flavor of the cake, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.
  • Cake Base (9%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the base, describing it as lovely, fantastic, and yummy.
  • Overall Flavor (38%): A substantial number of customers loved the flavor, describing it as good, great, and wonderful.

Review topics: ["flavor","delivery","chocolate","ice cream","base","texture","gift","boston cream pie","customer service","treat","pint","fudge","idea","pieces","hit","swirl","balance","combination","cream","pie","jeni","custard"].

Review highlights

  • "Great smooth texture and perfect flavor!" — Jenni R.
  • "Delicious flavors excellent delivery and user friendly website." — Sandi L.
  • "Boston cream pie is a delicious flavor." — Josh S.

Reviews

Best get well gift!

"My good friend (who happens to love ice cream) is recovering from surgery. We sent her 5 pints of Jenni’s. She was so surprised and so happy. She loves every flavor we sent her."

— Annie F. (5/5)

True to its name!

"I'd actually give this more like a 4. 5-star rating, but you're not giving me that option. . ."

— Phyllis D. (4/5)

My son’s favorite

"This is literally the best store bought ice cream on the market"

— Valerie L. (5/5)

Consistenly great

"Always delicious. The fudge is so good. Everyone in my family loves this flavor!"

— Mary C. (5/5)

Hooked!!

"OMG! We are obsessed! We received 5 pints as a sympathy gift and now we’re hooked! We recently sent a relative in Boston a gift package as a thank you gift And now they are hooked too! Of course we sent Boston Cream Pie lol. They are hoping that their local grocery store sells it"

— Suzanne C. (5/5)

Very good

"Very nice."

— Tracy W. (5/5)

Superb

"Excellent product, customer service and delivery!"

— Matt K. (5/5)

BEST EVER!

"Please never discontinue the Boston Cream Pie ice cream! I is sooooo good and so hard to find at markets. Our local market has it sometimes but it sells out fast. Perfect ratio of all the good stuff-LOVE!"

— JAMES (5/5)

5 star gift

"The recipients of my gift loved it! They are Jeni's fans and enjoyed their Christmas gift very much. They raved about the packaging and how hard the ice cream was upon arrival. I would definitely give Jeni's as a gift again. Also, I appreciate your excellent customer service changing the shipping week for me, as I failed to check the later shipping week I wanted. 5 star service, 5 star gift! Thank you!"

— Thais H. (5/5)

WOWZA

"No notes. Should be available in stores everywhere. Literally delicious and addictive."

— Kathryn F. (5/5)

Q&A