Skip to content
Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.9069767 / 5 from 86 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Burnt Orange Dreamsicle offers a rich and pleasantly bittersweet flavor, combining the classic orange-vanilla combo with new harmonies. The ice cream is highly praised for its juicy and robust taste, while the flavor is described as amazing, bright, and delicious.

Summary topics

  • Ice Cream Quality: 46%
  • Flavor Profile: 36%

Review topics: ["flavor","bite","delivery","order","gift","customer service","texture","ice cream","favorite","orange","peppermint","idea","caramel","orange dreamsicle","pint"].

Review highlights

  • "Recipient was so excited and pleased with the idea and the ice cream."Joy H.
  • "and we were all beyond delighted with the flavor and quality of the ice cream!"Susan D.
  • "Jeni’s ice cream is creamy and delicious, made with beautiful grass-pastured milk!"Julie R.

Reviews

My Husband enjoyed it all himself!

"I purchased five Jeni’s ice creams for delivery. Our local country store doesn’t always carry our favorite flavors, so on occasion, I order some of our favorites. I always order one extra flavor to try out. My husband ate all of the Burnt Orange Dreamsicle and I didn’t even get to sample it. He said it was delicious. Thank you."

Amy H. (5/5)

Unexpectedly great!

"I ordered this with a little reservation. Having been a Creamsicle / Dreamsicle fan since I was a small child, this one was too intriguing not to try! I was surprised at how good it is. Honestly, I could not imagine 'burnt" orange to be a positive, but it is! It's luxurious and elevated in an unexpected treat!"

Sam Y. (5/5)

Amazing

"I love ice cream. And I love just about every flavor that Jeni's puts out, yet every now & then a flavor surfaces that strikes me as being extraordinary, and Burnt Orange Dreamsicle is one of them. It's now in my top 3 FLOATs. . . . favorite FLavors of All Time. I don't think any flavor will ever knock Strawberry Buttermilk out of first place for me, but this one and Salty Caramel are neck and neck for places 2 and 3!"

Don B. (5/5)

The best flavor

"This is my favorite. I will stock up whenever I see it in stores. Its so good! The orange sauce is the like the best marmalade you ever tasted 😋 and its no sherbet a true orange icecream its so good"

Lauren H. (5/5)

All-time favorite

"This is hands down my all-time favorite ice cream flavor. It’s perfect. It’s caramel-y and fruity. If you love orange, you will love this. Please never ever stop making this perfect flavor!!"

jlhm (5/5)

Sooo good!

"Burnt orange creamsicle is sooo good especially paired with the darkest chocolate flavor. Yummy 😋"

Deborah T. (5/5)

My ice creams

"Burnt orange dream was amazing. Tasted just like I thought and hoped it would"

Julie L. (4/5)

Love it

"Love the flavor - the combo of the caramel and the orange sherbet type ice cream is so good!"

Sharon R. (5/5)

Great Gift!

"Sent as a gift, they loved every bite!"

Stacy M. (5/5)

Ice cream gift

"Arrived on time and in great condition and recipient was very happy."

Melinda H. (5/5)

Q&A