Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.902439 / 5 from 82 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Burnt Orange Dreamsicle offers a rich and pleasantly bittersweet flavor, combining the classic orange-vanilla combo with new harmonies. The ice cream is highly praised for its juicy and robust taste, while the flavor is described as amazing, bright, and delicious.

Summary topics

  • Ice Cream Quality: 46%
  • Flavor Profile: 36%

Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","gift","order","customer service","texture","favorite","ice cream","bite","orange","orange dreamsicle","pint","peppermint","idea","caramel"].

Review highlights

  • "Recipient was so excited and pleased with the idea and the ice cream."Joy H.
  • "and we were all beyond delighted with the flavor and quality of the ice cream!"Susan D.
  • "Jeni’s ice cream is creamy and delicious, made with beautiful grass-pastured milk!"Julie R.

Reviews

Amazing

"I love ice cream. And I love just about every flavor that Jeni's puts out, yet every now & then a flavor surfaces that strikes me as being extraordinary, and Burnt Orange Dreamsicle is one of them. It's now in my top 3 FLOATs. . . . favorite FLavors of All Time. I don't think any flavor will ever knock Strawberry Buttermilk out of first place for me, but this one and Salty Caramel are neck and neck for places 2 and 3!"

Don B. (5/5)

Sooo good!

"Burnt orange creamsicle is sooo good especially paired with the darkest chocolate flavor. Yummy 😋"

Deborah T. (5/5)

My ice creams

"Burnt orange dream was amazing. Tasted just like I thought and hoped it would"

Julie L. (4/5)

Love it

"Love the flavor - the combo of the caramel and the orange sherbet type ice cream is so good!"

Sharon R. (5/5)

Great Gift!

"Sent as a gift, they loved every bite!"

Stacy M. (5/5)

Ice cream gift

"Arrived on time and in great condition and recipient was very happy."

Melinda H. (5/5)

Thank you

"Thank you for the Ice Cream. . . delicious. AND most of all thank you for the customer service in replacing the order that UPS delayed. Thank you again. Todd Wear"

Todd W. (5/5)

Orange dreamy dreamsicle

"Creamy. Nice blend of orange and vanilla. Perfect for a hot summer day."

Jeanne M. (5/5)

Disappointed with Delivery

"My Jeni’s order was delivered to the bottom of my property by my staked address, in the sun delivery time 8/8:30am. I did not know the package was delivered; my Gardner didn’t know what the box was and I thought it part of tool storage. All deliveries are placed up by my garage by all the other carriers. Needless the ice cream was melted and a neighbor finally brought the box up to the garage. Yes, I live on the side of a mountain; I don’t expect deliveries down by the road."

Carol B. (5/5)

Malik brown Morgan

"Absolutely loved this flavor, reminds me a creamsicle very nostalgic. Great flavor"

Malik B. (5/5)

Q&A