• Pint of Jeni's Buttercream Birthday Cake ice cream topped with rainbow sprinkles

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7034483 / 5 from 145 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

This Buttercream Birthday Cake is celebrated for its rich vanilla and butter flavor, nostalgic and comforting texture, and delightful colorful sprinkles. Customers highly appreciate it as a gift, considering it the best they've ever received.

Summary topics

  • Flavor (38%): Many customers brought up the amazing flavor of this product, making it their new all-time favorite.
  • Gift Value (7%): Customers expressed appreciation for the gift, with many considering it the best gift they've ever received.
  • Sprinkle Quality (10%): Customers raved about the colorful sprinkles and the delicious buttercream ice cream in the cake.

Review topics: [flavor, delivery, packaging, order, gift, customer service, texture, ice cream, treat, base, crunch, cake, aftertaste, sprinkles, surprise, cow, pieces, cake bits, biscuits, fan, service, birthday].

Review highlights

  • "Amazing ice cream, insanely high quality flavors and textures." — Jocelyn J.
  • "My husband loves the cake, sprinkles and delicious buttercream ice cream." — Sherry D.
  • "Love the variety of flavors - great gift as all the recipients love to receive the Jeni’s box." — wendy m.

Reviews

She said it was all INCREDIBLE!

"There was an address mix up— thanks so much for pushing through that, persisting and getting it to someone badly in need of a big treat! Thank you! Greatly appreciated."

— Claire B. (5/5)

Everyone’s favorites

"We LOVE all Jeni’s flavors with the chocolate ones being the stand-outs, especially for the kids. Salted caramel is the favorite of grandma. Still so many more flavors to discover!"

— Lise C. (5/5)

My favorite

"This one is my favorite so far! Icing, bits of cake—I’ll be back for more"

— Leah D. (5/5)

Amazing flavor

"It tastes like you are eating a container of buttercream frosting or licking frosting off of a cupcake. Highly recommend."

— Shane C. (5/5)

Delicious but…carrageenan?

"This was my favorite ice cream, hands down. Good ingredients and excellent flavor. However, the last time I purchased this is noticed the ingredients have changed and not carrageenan is on the list. That is a no go for me. And, I hate that Jenni’s did this."

— DB (3/5)

Love Vanilla with Cake

"Loved it"

— Shellie P. (5/5)

My favorite and now it’s gluten free!

"This was my favorite ice cream for years. When I learned that I had to switch to a gluten free diet, I missed this ice cream so much. It’s finally gluten free, tastes the same as when it wasn’t gluten free, and now I’m back to buying it regularly! It’s so delicious. Takes me back to 90s birthday parties."

— Leilani (5/5)

Yum yum

"Mmmm this one is my number one favorite. The crunchy pint is a winner in my heart"

— Hannah R. (5/5)

Birthday Go To

"This ice cream delivers as a birthday treat! It is super full of sprinkles and the cake bits are delicious and sweet!"

— Taylor M. (5/5)

Where did the flower sprinkles go?!?!

"I’ve been buying this ice cream for months now, it’s my girlfriend’s favorite. She specifically goes crazy for the two types of sprinkles. Where did the flower sprinkles go!!!? 10 dollars a pint and no warning about a change of recipe is just upsetting!"

— Mark L. (3/5)

Q&A