Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

  •
  • Cookies in Cream Pint Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.6689653 / 5 from 145 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Cookies in Cream offers a deeply chocolaty, truffle-like cookie experience with a vanilla-scented cream that has buttery flecks of white chocolate. Customers praise its great flavor and its suitability as a gift, especially for gluten-free families. Best enjoyed under a blanket fort with a flashlight.

Summary topics

  • Gift Suitability: 8%
  • Cookies and Cream Quality: 14%
  • Flavor Quality: 31%

Review topics: [flavor, shipping, gift, order, treat, texture, favorite, cookies, chocolate, ice cream, cream, ice, staple, cake, hit, pint, version, jeni, hands, place].

Review highlights

  • "We thought this was the absolute best cookies and cream ice cream ever." — Jacquie G.
  • "Thrilled to have a gluten-free cookies and cream option." — Melanie H.
  • "Very high quality flavor and texture." — Jocelyn J.

Reviews

Shockingly good from house-made cookies

"I don't even usually like cookies and cream flavor that much but this one was gone in one sitting. Can't wait to buy it again. I think the cookies are far tastier than usual because of the house recipe using rice and buckwheat flour iirc. I love buckwheat flour crackers already, so their flavor in this ice cream is divine. Before reading the ingredient list, I couldn't name why the ice cream was so good, and you certainly can't consciously taste buckwheat, but I'm guessing whatever mild undertones it has is what may be lifting this flavor to extreme exceptionalism. Well done Jeni's! Who could have guessed that a cookies and cream ice cream flavor could vie for placement of my all-time-favorite?"

— Anna G. (5/5)

Family favorite!

"Better than you imagine and how can you go wrong with cookies and cream. The family fights for this one and I finally scored a few bites! So good!!"

— Kelly L. (4/5)

Delicious

"Your ice creams are a little pricey but omg, delicious!"

— Rose R. (5/5)

Cookies and cream

"Would have liked bigger cookie pieces"

— Julia l. (3/5)

Absolutely Delicious

"I've ordered a couple times already and I will keep on ordering! Specially my personal fave the Mint Chocolate Chip ! That is dangerously scrumptious ! My son is enjoying all the flavors as well ! I hate the shipping is so expensive tho. . . It'll keep me from ordering as much as I desire to. ."

— ALMA G. (5/5)

Debra meyer

"Wonderful delivery! Delicious ice cream!"

— Debra M. (5/5)

Best cookies & cream

"A new fav! Please make available in Whole Foods!"

— Otira J. (5/5)

Reorder, reorder, reorder!

"Your ice cream has something special about it that you just can't get anywhere else. I love the gluten-free flavors - little happy place in my kitchen. Thank you for being cool. . ."

— Amber C. (5/5)

Best GF cookies and cream

"My husband was so excited to be able to have a cookies and cream ice cream (he’s gluten free)! He said it was delicious!"

— Mara E. (5/5)

Yum!

"This gf cookies and cream ice cream hit the spot. It’s one of the flavors of ice cream that seldom come gf. Now I buy it regularly from Jenni’s along with their many other gf flavors."

— Jeanne R. (5/5)

Q&A