Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8955226 / 5 from 268 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Darkest Chocolate ice cream is crafted with top-tier Fair Trade cocoa, offering a rich, bittersweet chocolate flavor that is dense yet creamy, making it a standout choice for chocolate lovers. Its exceptional taste and creamy texture have been highly praised by customers, and it is also considered a perfect gift for various occasions.

Summary topics

  • Chocolate Flavor: 26%
  • Gift Suitability: 10%

Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","gift","order","chocolate","treat","husband","service","favorite","ice cream","jeni","balance","friend","brand","christmas","cream","caramel","idea","jeni\u2019s"].

Review highlights

  • "Dark deep rich chocolate taste but not too sweet."Sheila G.
  • "The delivery service is a great resource for sending an unexpected gift."Erin G.
  • "Delicious ice cream with the absolute best flavors."Erin G.

Reviews

This should be illegal! 😂

"Best ice cream I’ve had in a long time. Found this when I was on a trip. Unfortunately, I can’t find it where I live so I had to order it. That’s how much I enjoy it."

Michelle T. (5/5)

Love the dark chocolate

"The best chocolate ice cream I have ever had!"

Michelle R. (5/5)

Still the best

"I think this is by far the best chocolate ice cream that is commercially available in the United States. However, I noticed that since the packaging changed, and there are slightly different nutritional values on the package such as the calorie count. that it appears to me that the taste is slightly less intense. Possibly, it is just my imagination, but I also believe the chocolate does not appear as dark as previously. I still feel that this is the best chocolate ice cream available. Is this my imagination or have others experienced the same. I am still hooked on this ice cream and will continue to be a purchaser at my local Whole Foods."

JMF (5/5)

Great

"I'm a chocolate lover and this was the greatest ever."

Myra M. (5/5)

Amazing!

"How do you choose?"

Deborah M. (5/5)

you’ve ruined me for all other chocolate

"Holy cow. This was one of the best chocolate flavors I’ve ever had. I bought another very popular brand after this and it put it to shame. You’ve ruined me! ❤️"

bettina p. (5/5)

texas, jelly, banana, dark choc.

"all of the flavors were amazing !!"

Deb B. (5/5)

Heaven

"My absolute favorite and its not crazy sweet like some of the ice cream flavors. heavenly"

Stephanie M. (5/5)

Want more!

"I would love it if it were stocked in my store!"

Elizabeth B. (5/5)

Extremely Intense Chocolate Flavor - The Best

"My years long search for the best chocolate ice cream is finally over! Really intense flavor and perfect texture."

Ann C. (5/5)

Q&A