• Pint of Jeni's Double Dough ice cream, a tan pint with cookie dough chunks visible
  • Close-up texture of Double Dough ice cream with cookie dough chunks and chocolate chips

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7958117 / 5 from 191 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Double Dough ice cream offers a rich and buttery cookie dough experience with creamy custard, brown sugar notes, and chocolate chip cookie dough pieces. While many customers love the flavor and texture, opinions on the size of the cookie dough pieces vary.

Summary topics

  • Cookie Dough Texture (26%): A significant number of customers appreciated the raw cookie dough, considering it the best they have ever tasted.
  • Custard Creaminess (4%): Customers expressed appreciation for the super creamy custard with buttery, salty, brown sugar notes.
  • Cookie Dough Piece Size (6%): Customers expressed differing viewpoints regarding the pieces, with some finding them too small and others wishing for larger pieces.
  • Overall Flavor Satisfaction (51%): Many customers expressed satisfaction with the flavor, describing it as the best they have ever had. (9 out of 20 reviews)

Review topics: [flavor, delivery, gift, order, base, chocolate, treat, ice cream, texture, dough, pieces, jeni, chunks, custard, pint, perfection, jeni’s, shop, bring, choice, flavor of all time].

Review highlights

  • "The dough is perfect size and the custard is so delicious." — Brandon D.
  • "One of my favorite flavors of all time, no surprise Jeni's version is superior." — Jocelyn J.
  • "I absolutely LOVE Double Dough and it is my new favorite flavor of Jeni's ice cream." — Holly M.

Reviews

The best cookie dough ice cream hands down

"this is one is in my top 5 favorite flavors. Flavor is so far above any other cookie dough themed ice cream i've had. I can't figure out what it is that is putting it over the top but it is working."

— Katrina H. (5/5)

Very few and tiny chunks of cookie dough

"This ice cream tastes great. The problem? Saying it has double cookie dough is a joke. And each piece is smaller than a pea. If anything it has LESS cookie dough than some of the other premium brands. Disappointing."

— 1/2 b. (3/5)

Double Dough

"I always loved cookie dough ice cream, and this one was very delicious."

— Michelle S. (5/5)

Favorite!

"In my opinion by far the best flavor Jeni’s has ever made (tied with gooey butter cake). I love that every bit of the ice cream tastes like cookie dough. Yum!"

— Jessica (5/5)

So good

"Best ice cream I’ve ever had"

— Carrie W. (5/5)

Not what I expected

"To my delight, it wasn’t what I expected. I thought it would be vanilla ice cream with lots of cookie dough. But, the ice cream was cookie dough flavor with some chocolate chip cookie dough pieces. The ice cream really was amazing!!"

— Kathy R. (5/5)

Current favorite

"I really like this ice cream. It has a brown butter cookie taste that is delicious"

— Atr (5/5)

The Best Cookie Dough Ice Cream Ever

"I was never a fan of cookie dough ice cream until I tried this one. It's perfect in every way. I pair it with the Sweet Cream flavor. It's one of my favorite combos of your ice cream flavors."

— Debbie G. (5/5)

What sorcery is this?

"I’m totally addicted to the Double Dough. I don’t even like ice cream but somehow, someway, Jeni’s has made me a loyal follower. I actually have dreams that I’m eating it."

— Carrie T. (5/5)

Hmmm

"This is very good, however the brown sugar icecream is not giving brown sugar. I love the concept and the cookie dough bits were insanely good, but the actual icecream was just not it."

— Kathryn F. (4/5)

Q&A