Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7962384 / 5 from 319 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Goat Cheese with Red Cherries is highly praised for its perfect blend of delicate goat cheese and tart cherries, offering a sweet-tart flavor that customers love. The combination of cream and cherries is noted for its balance and phenomenal texture, making it a favorite among ice cream enthusiasts.

Summary topics

  • Goat Cheese Flavor (14%): Customers appreciated the goat cheese and cherries, describing it as DELICIOUS and their all-time favorite.
  • Cherry Flavor (27%): A significant number of customers loved the tart and juicy cherries in the Goat Cheese with Red Cherries.
  • Blend of Flavors (3%): It was highlighted by customers that the blend of goat cheese and tart cherry ice cream is perfect.
  • Balance of Cream and Cherries (4%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the perfect balance of cream and cherries in the goat cheese.
  • Product Texture (4%): It was reported by customers that the texture of the product is phenomenal and perfect for all tastes.

Review topics: ["flavor","quality","delivery","issue","combo","texture","gift","order","blend","mouth","compliment","ice cream","treat","goodness","mix","cherries","ingredients","winner","sweetness","goat cheese","combination","jeni","balance","pint","cream","cheesecake","tartness","pairing","freezer","tang"].

Review highlights

  • "This was amazing - the tart cherries combined with the rich goat cheese was a perfect combination."Darcy Z.
  • "The goat cheese ice cream was so smooth and creamy, and those cherries were the perfect compliment."Chrysta B.
  • "Perfect balance between a special, unique cream with a lingering taste and slightly tangy cherries."Bruce M.

Reviews

The Cherry Has Main Character Energy

"Jeni’s Goat Cheese & Red Cherries is proof that opposites don’t just attract—they throw fabulous dinner parties. The cherries arrive sweet, tart, and dripping with confidence, while the goat cheese adds a creamy tang that politely reminds everyone it’s too sophisticated for ordinary cheesecake. Together, they’re a perfect balance of bold and refined, like a ballerina who secretly rides a motorcycle. Every spoonful is bright, rich, and just a little dramatic. The cherries flirt, the goat cheese rolls its eyes, and somehow they end up being the happiest couple in the freezer."

Faithe H. (5/5)

No notes!

"I think the tart cherries are what really make this! My first taste of the cherry part was a eureka moment! Thankful that it's not overly sweet so the tangy flavors are allowed to shine. A cheesecake style icecream that actually delivers on the cheesiness."

Casey G. (5/5)

Goat Cheese with Red Cherries

"Someone in a chat room told me about this flavor. It is absolutely delicious and fresh tasting. Taste like cheesecake. I love goat cheese."

Michelle S. (5/5)

The classics endure for a reason

"All that it promised and more: It's easy to see why this is such a longstanding flavor. It's rare to find in stores these days, so (going forward), whenever I see it I will buy it."

Nick R. (5/5)

Intriguing flavor

"The pairing is really unique. This is a flavor I got out of curiosity, and was pleased by the smooth, scoopable texture it had. The cherry and cheese go well together, but it had a “goat-y” aftertaste that I’m not too fond of. As always, the ice cream quality is very nice. 👍"

Erica G. (4/5)

Not at all cheesy

"I had already tasted this at the store, so I knew I was getting something good—and I was right!"

Phyllis D. (5/5)

Goat Cheese with Cherries

"Please don't ever stop making this!!!"

Vicki C. (5/5)

WOW! JUST . . . WOW!!!

"The goat cheese with cherries is beyond words. Subtle sweetness and the balance of the slightly salty goat cheese. Unreal!!!!"

Ken (5/5)

Yummy

"Flavors were good except I didn’t care for the sorbet"

Yvonne N. (5/5)

Love

"Shockingly delicious. Very rich"

CASEY O. (5/5)

Q&A