LAST CHANCE: Buy 5 pints, get the 6th free! Code: FREEPINT

  • Pint of Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake ice cream, a pink pint with a spoon topped with cream scoops
  • Close-up texture of Gooey Butter Cake ice cream with a cake crumble swirl

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.803681 / 5 from 163 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Gooey Butter Cake ice cream captures the essence of a beloved regional dessert with its rich, buttery flavor and creamy texture. Customers appreciate its gluten-free option and rave about its delicious taste, making it a favorite treat for many.

Summary topics

  • Flavor: 40%
  • Texture: 7%
  • Treat Experience: 8%
  • Gluten-Free Option: 6%

Review topics: ["flavor","bite","quality","order","price","gift","selection","ice cream","texture","treat","chocolate","pieces","gluten","cake","jeni","pint"].

Review highlights

  • "The smooth texture of the ice cream mixed with the cake was the perfect marriage of flavors for this super tasty treat" — Shay J.
  • "Flavor was incredible, texture was so creamy and smooth." — Alyssa H.
  • "Delicious flavor with smooth texture and delicious chewy bites!" — Kimberly C.

Reviews

Delicious Ice Cream!

"I ordered & sent this ice cream to my son & his family. They LOVED all the flavors; especially the Brambleberry Crisp. He said it was the best carton ice cream he has ever tasted; the texture was so smooth & creamy!"

— Jean O. (5/5)

Oh My YUUUUUM

"Bites of cake! OHMYGOD! This was so rich and sweet! Made my heart ache with love. 😭 Idk how they infused nostalgia to the flavor but it was awesome. 10/10 no notes."

— Kay (5/5)

Love at first bite

"I was in love at first bite. Best ice cream flavor I've ever experienced, hands down."

— Sigrid O. (5/5)

Tu

"I’m not the biggest fan of the cheesecake flavor. It’d be just as good or better with just plain vanilla."

— Anna U. (5/5)

Great selection of flavors!

"All luscious flavors."

— Grace C. (5/5)

Best ice cream out there

"This is one of my husband’s favorites. He said he can’t go wrong with it."

— Aoril J. (5/5)

Gooey

"Scrumptious"

— Brittany M. (5/5)

Like a chess bar

"A classic but a little too sweet."

— Laura C. (5/5)

Very impressed with the selections

"My daughter liked zit was underwhelming for me. Good but not a favorite"

— vanietta a. (4/5)

The best gluten-free one.

"This is the best one of all of the gluten-free flavors. . . Just in case anybody was wondering."

— Amber C. (5/5)

Q&A