• Pint of Jeni's Gooey Butter Cake ice cream, a pink pint with a spoon topped with cream scoops
  • Close-up texture of Gooey Butter Cake ice cream with a cake crumble swirl

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8023953 / 5 from 167 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Gooey Butter Cake ice cream captures the essence of a beloved regional dessert with its rich, buttery flavor and creamy texture. Customers appreciate its gluten-free option and rave about its delicious taste, making it a favorite treat for many.

Summary topics

  • Flavor (40%): A substantial number of customers raved about the flavor, describing it as great, amazing, and the best they've ever had.
  • Texture (7%): Customers raved about the creamy and rich texture, with many describing it as creamy and smooth.
  • Treat Experience (8%): It was noted by customers that this treat is their favorite and an absolute treat, making it a favorite choice.
  • Gluten-Free Option (6%): Customers expressed appreciation for the gluten-free flavor, which was mentioned multiple times in the reviews.

Review topics: [flavor, bite, quality, order, price, selection, gift, ice cream, texture, treat, chocolate, pieces, gluten, cake, jeni, pint].

Review highlights

  • "The smooth texture of the ice cream mixed with the cake was the perfect marriage of flavors for this super tasty treat" — Shay J.
  • "Flavor was incredible, texture was so creamy and smooth." — Alyssa H.
  • "Delicious flavor with smooth texture and delicious chewy bites!" — Kimberly C.

Reviews

Almost perfect

"Great number of pastry pieces, great cream flavor and consistency- the only demerit is a slightly underwhelming sense of butter and salt in the mixture. You can tell what it is, but the best gooey butter cake really hammers home the salted butter flavor. This could use a bit more."

— Josh A. (4/5)

Loved it!

"First time ordering, everything arrived in a nice insulated package. Flavors were amazing and unique. Will definitely be ordering again as all the flavors are not available where I live."

— Angie O. (5/5)

Delicious Ice Cream!

"I ordered & sent this ice cream to my son & his family. They LOVED all the flavors; especially the Brambleberry Crisp. He said it was the best carton ice cream he has ever tasted; the texture was so smooth & creamy!"

— Jean O. (5/5)

Gooey Butter Cake

"Favorite ice cream!! Creamy and smooth with chunks of yummy cake and butterscotch ribbon."

— wendy s. (5/5)

10/10

"This is my go-to ice cream at Jeni's. Its a classic and I love how smooth it is."

— Ashley J. (5/5)

Oh My YUUUUUM

"Bites of cake! OHMYGOD! This was so rich and sweet! Made my heart ache with love. 😭 Idk how they infused nostalgia to the flavor but it was awesome. 10/10 no notes."

— Kay (5/5)

It’s my favorite!!

"I can stop enjoying this flavor !! It’s tooo good!!"

— Katherine D. (5/5)

Love at first bite

"I was in love at first bite. Best ice cream flavor I've ever experienced, hands down."

— Sigrid O. (5/5)

Tu

"I’m not the biggest fan of the cheesecake flavor. It’d be just as good or better with just plain vanilla."

— Anna U. (5/5)

Great selection of flavors!

"All luscious flavors."

— Grace C. (5/5)

Q&A