• Pint of Jeni's High Five Candy Bar ice cream, a tan pint with a pretzel graphic topped with chocolate-swirled scoops

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.729614 / 5 from 233 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

High Five Candy Bar combines peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels, and honey for a delightful, multi-textured treat. Customers love the perfect balance of crunchy and smooth caramel, the salty sweetness of the crunch, and the dreamy, nougat-y flavor from the honey.

Summary topics

  • Caramel Balance (5%): Customers keep praising the incredible flavor and perfect balance of crunchy and smooth caramel in the product.
  • Crunch and Saltiness (5%): Customers raved about the crunch and salty sweetness of this creamed peanut butter candy bar.
  • Candy Bar Incorporation (9%): Customers expressed appreciation for the candy bar, stating it is their favorite and perfectly incorporated into the ice cream.
  • Overall Flavor (42%): A substantial number of customers pointed out that the flavor of this product is loved and highly praised.

Review topics: ["flavor","selection","crunch","order","texture","blend","favorite","ice cream","goodness","treat","ingredients","five candy bar","chocolate","tooth","combo","caramel","gift","pretzels","jeni","peanut butter","combination","pieces","notes","crunchy","story","amount","ordering","pint"].

Review highlights

  • "Incredible flavor, perfect balance of crunchy and smooth caramel." — Mikki-Jean B.
  • "Take your time to savor all the different textures and flavors of this most indulgent flavor!!" — Amy B.
  • "This was a gift, so I did not have opportunity to try these delicious looking flavors." — Edward L.

Reviews

2 scoops is all you need

"This super premium ice cream has everything for the chocolate and peanut butter lover. Very rich and decadent. You don’t need much to satisfy your urge for a special dessert."

— DAVID L. (5/5)

Like a Take 5 Candy Bar, but Better

"The flavor combo is familiar and fantastic. The salty and sweet ingredients hit all the right notes that you'd get from a candy bar made with similar ingredients, but the creamy ice cream takes this treat to the next level."

— Adam S. (5/5)

I liked the ice cream with candy

"This was good. Could not find anything like this at the grocery store."

— Shellie P. (4/5)

Strawberry Pretzel Pie is to DIE for!

"I’m a chocoholic and usually gravitate to all things chocolate,but the Strawberry Pretzel Pie was to DIE for! The Key Lime Pie is also a fave and wild love to see that on the regular rotation!!"

— Marianne O. (5/5)

Best Ever ! !

"Absolutely love the High Five Candy Bar. Have to have a scoop or two every day. The best!!"

— Carole S. (5/5)

Recommend Jeni’s.

"All of these flavors are highly recommended. Hard to rank as all are number 1."

— Debbie B. (5/5)

No notes

"Pb lovers will love this flavor sweet and a little salty with pretzel bites 10/10"

— Ashley S. (5/5)

A Bit Too Much For Me

"Can’t believe I’m saying this but this ice cream is a bit too much for me! It’s so jam packed with additional ingredients that I missed the ice cream! People who like lots of ingredients will probably love it."

— Ann C. (4/5)

My favs. . . High Five Candy Bar and Savannah Buttermint

"High Five Candy Bar. . . . reordered this one along with Savannah Buttermint. Absolutely delicious. . . just the right amount of candy and chocolate. Can't wait for my next shipment this week."

— Peg C. (5/5)

The BEST ice cream!

"Delicious- this is the best combo of mix-ins!"

— Cescile H. (5/5)

Q&A