Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7292576 / 5 from 229 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

High Five Candy Bar combines peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels, and honey for a delightful, multi-textured treat. Customers love the perfect balance of crunchy and smooth caramel, the salty sweetness of the crunch, and the dreamy, nougat-y flavor from the honey.

Summary topics

  • Caramel Balance: 5%
  • Crunch and Saltiness: 5%
  • Candy Bar Incorporation: 9%
  • Overall Flavor: 42%

Review topics: ["flavor","gift","crunch","order","blend","texture","goodness","ice cream","treat","favorite","chocolate","five candy bar","tooth","ingredients","pretzels","caramel","jeni","pieces","peanut butter","combination","pint","amount","story","ordering","crunchy"].

Review highlights

  • "Incredible flavor, perfect balance of crunchy and smooth caramel."Mikki-Jean B.
  • "Take your time to savor all the different textures and flavors of this most indulgent flavor!!"Amy B.
  • "This was a gift, so I did not have opportunity to try these delicious looking flavors."Edward L.

Reviews

Best Ever ! !

"Absolutely love the High Five Candy Bar. Have to have a scoop or two every day. The best!!"

Carole S. (5/5)

Recommend Jeni’s.

"All of these flavors are highly recommended. Hard to rank as all are number 1."

Debbie B. (5/5)

No notes

"Pb lovers will love this flavor sweet and a little salty with pretzel bites 10/10"

Ashley S. (5/5)

A Bit Too Much For Me

"Can’t believe I’m saying this but this ice cream is a bit too much for me! It’s so jam packed with additional ingredients that I missed the ice cream! People who like lots of ingredients will probably love it."

Ann C. (4/5)

My favs. . . High Five Candy Bar and Savannah Buttermint

"High Five Candy Bar. . . . reordered this one along with Savannah Buttermint. Absolutely delicious. . . just the right amount of candy and chocolate. Can't wait for my next shipment this week."

Peg C. (5/5)

The BEST ice cream!

"Delicious- this is the best combo of mix-ins!"

Cescile H. (5/5)

Deliciousness

"Awesome ALL"

CLAUDIA K. (5/5)

Hands Down!

"Favorite! New All Time Favorite Hands down!!!"

M D. (5/5)

Good ice cream

"Good ice cream"

Prince J. (5/5)

Love it

"Love it"

Regina F. (4/5)

Q&A