Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8074074 / 5 from 135 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Lemon Bar offers a delightful balance of sweet and tart flavors with a creamy coconut base. Customers praise its delicious lemon flavor, creamy texture, and the perfect harmony of lemon curd and shortbread crumbles, making it a standout dairy-free treat.

Summary topics

  • Lemon Flavor: 13%
  • Lemon Bar Texture: 12%
  • Overall Flavor: 40%
  • Lemon Curd Tanginess: 10%

Review topics: ["flavor","packaging","gift","order","texture","lemon","treat","ice cream","combo","lemon bar","lemon curd","dairy","pint","coconut","pieces","option","combination","cake","cream","tartness","recipients","shortbread","dessert","tier","swirl"].

Review highlights

  • "The absolute best lemon curd and creamy coconut flavor!"Anita A.
  • "The recipients LOVED every flavor and were impressed by the packaging."REBECCA C.
  • "Jeni’s Lemon Bar is the very best alternative ice cream I’ve ever tasted."Patricia H.

Reviews

Needs more lemon

"I really wanted to love this, but 2 things interfered. First, the coconut taste from the coconut cream dominates the flavor of the lemon. That should not be the case in a flavor called “Lemon Bar. ” The taste was not bad, but it didn’t taste like a lemon bar. Second, it lacks the level of creaminess I’ve come to expect from Jeni’s. This isn’t a deal breaker for a non-dairy dessert, but the difference is noticeable."

LYNN W. (3/5)

Lemon Bar

"The Lemon Bar is an absolutely perfect blend of sweet and tart. Puckered my mouth !! 💛🍋"

Tanna K. (5/5)

Great

"I love all things lemon, this is really really great. The shortbread pieces were great I personally could do with more lemon curd. The coconut cream does balance out the tartness of the curd."

Rachael (5/5)

Lemon Goodness

"Very good! Love the tartness and the sweetness! Great Combo"

Debbie G. (5/5)

FABULOUS

"This is so good that I think they must serve it in heaven."

Jennie (5/5)

Nice and light.

"A real surprise with great flavor and lightness."

Michael H. (5/5)

Very impressed with the selection

"I am a citrus person so the Lemon Bar already a favorite refreshing with the right amount of citrus like having a elevated lemon sorbet at your disposal Will definitely order again"

vanietta a. (5/5)

Lemony Goodness

"I like the tart and sweet together. The bits of shortbread are nice too."

Crystal W. (5/5)

Tasty

"Very delicious"

LEE B. (5/5)

$$$

"A fave, lemony and lemon pie texture. Too costly."

Mick M. (5/5)

Q&A