Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.7482014 / 5 from 139 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Milkiest Chocolate is highly praised for its creamy and silky texture, which customers love. The flavor is described as great, perfect, deep, and creamy, making it a favorite among chocolate lovers. It is also appreciated as a perfect gift for ice cream lovers.

Summary topics

  • Gift Quality: 6%
  • Flavor Profile: 30%
  • Texture Quality: 10%

Review topics: ["flavor","packaging","gift","order","chocolate","customer service","ice cream","jeni","staff"].

Review highlights

  • "The saltiness brought out the chocolate beautifully, and the texture was so silky and creamy."Courtney A.
  • "Smooth creamy rich taste with no aftertaste."Denise D.
  • "Again, simple flavor, but best ingredients and therefore best simple chocolate ice cream."Nicole K.

Reviews

Mom who?

"This is a good "mom needs a moment" flavor! Hide in the pantry, get a few bites in. Taste the stress melting away!"

Kelly L. (4/5)

Best chocolate ic

"My fav chocolate ice cream of all time! Super smooth & delectable!"

Katie M. (5/5)

Good

"Pretty Rich. It was nothing special"

Julie L. (4/5)

Loved it!!

"The Milkiest Chocolate is so creamy and tasty."

Kathy R. (5/5)

Always a fav!

"This one is my daughter’s favorite. Any order requires at least 2 pints of this for her."

Nicole K. (5/5)

Lavender

"Got this for my neighbors! In love with milk chocolate!💝"

Melayne M. (5/5)

Review from Choctaw, Oklahoma

"My daughter and I loved the Bridgerton Queen Charlotte Sponge Cake, and all the other flavors we’ve tried. But, I truly miss the Brandied Banana Brûlé!"

Michele T. (5/5)

“Best chocolate ice cream ever”

"This is according to my 13 yo! He loves this ice cream and he typically eats vanilla only but he loves this one!"

Kyle K. (5/5)

Delicious Jeni’s Ice Cream

"All are so very delicious!"

Helen D. (5/5)

Pretty good

"If you want chocolate but not a overpowering chocolate - this one will get the job done!"

Johnette F. (5/5)

Q&A