Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.9117646 / 5 from 68 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Peppermint Patty offers a delightful mint-chocolate experience with a velvety coconut cream base, enhanced by pure peppermint flavor. Customers praise its delicious taste and buttery texture, making it a top choice for those seeking a refreshing and gourmet treat.

Summary topics

  • Ice Cream Quality (50%): A substantial number of customers remarked that the ice cream is the best they have ever had.
  • Flavor Quality (35%): A significant amount of customers expressed appreciation for the flavor, describing it as absolutely delicious and top-notch.

Review topics: ["flavor","quality","delivery","ice cream","packaging","gift","mint","jeni","chocolate","recipients","cream","option","jeni\u2019s","cake","dairy","coconut"].

Review highlights

  • "Jeni's ice creams are top notch and I haven't had a bad flavor yet." — Kim H.
  • "Loved this delicious GF and vegan ice cream- hope they continue to make this." — DD
  • "The flavors are unique and quality is top-notch!" — Cescile H.

Reviews

Peppermint Dream

"I am a proud vegan, and sometimes finding really good dairy-free flavors is difficult. This flavor was better than anything that I used to have that was made with diary products. I wanted to comment that many diary-free flavors have an almost chalky consistency, but this was smooth and creamy with a bright, refreshing pepperment flavor and decadent, rich, dark chocolate that was perfectly balanced. Thanks for thinking of those of us who do not eat dairy. This had the perfect vibe for the holidays. Highly recommend whether you eat dairy or not. Yummo!!"

— GretaJo (5/5)

ice cream

"I have not purchased for myself yet, but all the ice cream gifts have been very much liked and appreciated."

— Anne G. (5/5)

Happy Birthday

"I was given a gift certificate for my birthday. Enough to purchase six pints. There are several I really like. My first purchase, if available, will be Honey Vanila Bean which tastes nearly like the home made, hand cranked vanila ice cream I remember from 70 years ago. My wife's pick is Salted Peanut Butter. I was pleasantly surprised to find that my local grocery store has them in their freezer case."

— THOMAS H. (5/5)

Every Bite Better than the Last One

"We ordered and received a sweet pack of Jeni's to our home. It arrived frozen amid the hottest weather of the season here in Arizona! Thanks Jeni's! The flavors - spectacular, each one better than the one before. The Lemon Bar is truly exceptional, the Texas Sheet Cake and Peppermint Patty are creamy and luscious, and Biscuits with the Boss is unmatched. We don't have Jeni's in our local market, and this gift for my convalescing husband was a true delight. Yummmm."

— Deborah S. (5/5)

Yep. A dairy free winner.

"A great dairy free option. Lovely flavor all around. No complaints to be had."

— JIll B. (5/5)

Excellent!

"Everything was fantastic! The ice cream arrived on time just as you promised and the recipients enjoyed it greatly. Next time I want to send ice cream you will be my choice! Thank you!!!"

— Rosanne H. (5/5)

Wish I got to try it myself!

"My wife stole this one and ate it all. I think she liked it. Give 5 stars."

— Benjamin G. (5/5)

A Great Gift!

"I gave 5 pints to one friend who described it as wonderful and decedent. So I gave it to another friend who had equally terrific things to say, especially about the interesting and different flavors. It’s a keeper!"

— Gail G. (5/5)

Sooooo good

"Like I’m eating a peppermint patty I took out of the fridge. Cool and refreshing."

— Mary G. (5/5)

Peppermint Patty

"The Peppermint Patty is my favorite! Tastes just like the York patties!"

— Ryan B. (5/5)

Q&A