Reviews
Yummy Yummy
"I see why this flavor is a repeat seasonal option. It has a nice balance of all the ingredients you would find in a well made pumpkin pie. The blondies remind me of a buttery crust while the ice cream and swirl is a great filling. I would serve this as an alternate to pie or a dollop on top of an actual pumpkin pie! Would go back to order but sold out but always next season Yummy"
— vanietta a. (5/5)
Fall Comfort in a Pint
"Absolutely delicious! Great balance of spice, pumpkin and cream, making the ice cream not too sweet or too rich. It makes for a great base for the caramel and blondie pieces, both of which had perfect texture and taste. Personally, the way Jeni’s makes caramel evokes nostalgia, like eating the softest chew, and it adds a buttery richness that pairs deliciously with the pumpkin. Tasty, nostalgic flavors that are well-balanced and well-textured? Definitely the best pumpkin ice cream on the market."
— Nicholas (5/5)
Perfect for Fall
"I’ve had a tradition for the last 50+ years to try and have pumpkin ice cream during Oct/Nov. It was Baskin Robbin’s for many, many years but then I moved on to a brand that I could find locally. NOTHING has ever been as good as this! Flavor and texture are superb - it’s a total treat for the coming holidays - or now."
— Ann C. (5/5)
Top Fall Entry
"Loved this flavor! The blondies were a nice mix in, and I had to pace myself when eating it. Glad it wasn't just a flat base of pumpkin, which is boring imo. Sad I only bought 1 pint!"
— Sharayu H. (5/5)
I love Jeni’s ice cream
"So I love pumpkin and I thought you nailed it with this . So good !! My favorite is the watermelon taffy and the Wildberry lavender . So good as well"
— James C. (4/5)
Buy it!
"This is so good! I'm not usually a caramel girly but the taste and texture of this caramel is so good! Not too sweet. The blonde bits are nice with the subtle pumpkin ice cream"
— Regina M. (5/5)
My only vice is Jeni's
"I first discovered the Jeni's brand when it did a collab with Dolly Parton. I've since been a superfan preaching to all ice cream lovers how they must try Jeni's and which flavors I'm into at the moment. I look forward to the seasonal drops. I am grateful I get to visit the scoop shop in Philly when I visit my college student (NY needs one too). And I have so much fun selecting flavors for a 6-pack shipment to gift others as a surprise. I treasure hunt for flavors I haven't tried yet in my grocery stores. So far Whole Foods carries the most in my area. LOVE Jeni's."
— GENNIFER B. (5/5)
Love this stuff
"Simply delicious ice cream that is great in every way. The texture is great and so is the packaging. My favorite ice cream by far."
— Oliver C. (5/5)
ice cream was melted
"I didn't get to enjoy my order. All the ice cream was melted. Super bummed as I've tried some flavors before and they were delicious. Will stick to buying at the store."
— Elizabeth T. (3/5)
love
"this is a great flavor! good pumpkin and great brown sugar compliments to it"
— Kimberley M. (5/5)