Skip to content

Shop Father’s Day gifts now!

Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8047338 / 5 from 169 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Strawberry Buttermilk ice cream is celebrated for its bright, fresh strawberry flavor and smooth, creamy texture. While some customers love the strawberry buttermilk combination, opinions vary. The overall flavor is highly praised for being delicious and unique.

Summary topics

  • Strawberry Buttermilk: 4%
  • Strawberry Flavor: 15%
  • Creamy Texture: 5%
  • Overall Flavor: 51%

Review topics: ["flavor","selection","gift","order","texture","sweetness","goodness","ice cream","joy","strawberry","jeni","strawberry buttermilk","pint","cream","tang"].

Review highlights

  • "really really loved this flavor, the texture and the touch of buttermilk was perfect."Margaret W.
  • "Delicious flavor, perfect creamy texture."Holleen K.
  • "The sweet and creamy strawberry flavor with a hint of tartness is a perfect blend."Venice S.

Reviews

The taste of summer

"This is the FLOAT! My personal favorite FLavor of All Time. It's smooth and silky with a subtle and gentle bite of tang. The strawberry flavor reminds me of summer, and it brings me back to some fond childhood memories of starwberry picking and all that followed: jam, shortcake and a belly full of freshly picked berries in the field"

Don B. (5/5)

97 year old gave it a thumbs up

"We sent 5 pints to my mother in law for her Mother’s Day gift. She just turned 97 in April and is ecstatic with the selection we sent stating it was the very best."

Linda G. (5/5)

Strawberry Buttermilk

"Creamy and very good."

Andre'-P. F. (5/5)

Ta6

"Creamy and tasty"

LEE B. (4/5)

Great strawberry flavor

"We love this ice cream as well, we love strawberries and we love cream The texture of it is perfect and divine would order again"

Mary B. (5/5)

Tasty, but not the best

"It is certainly a tasty strawberry ice cream. However, while Jenni’s ice creams usually have a more nuanced and subtle edge compared to equivalent flavors from other brands, this one lacks that distinction. Additionally, the buttermilk flavor is far too faint."

Jon (3/5)

A Keeper

"Love the tangy sweet flavor, great texture. Will order again in the future."

Ann C. (5/5)

Absolutly love!

"Ok!!! I thought that the honey vanilla was my favorite BUT this strawberry is total fire!!!!!!! Absolutely LOVE it. Perfectly sweetened, creamy, with the essence of strawberry filling your mouth and senses."

Johnette F. (5/5)

Christmas gift

"All of our friends received their shipments on time, perfect condition and absolutely LOVED all the selections of ice- cream. Perfect gifts to send friends!"

wendy W. (5/5)

Strawberry Cream Dream

"Creamy and refreshing reminds me of the starbucks strawberry refresher"

Morgan M. (5/5)

Q&A