Maybe the best ice cream I’ve had in my life.
"Please consider bringing it back someday."
Collections ship free in the contiguous U.S.

Overall rating: 4.918919 / 5 from 37 reviews.
Sunshine ice cream offers a unique flavor experience with a mix of sunny citrus and tropical passion fruit, complemented by a bouncy texture. Customers appreciate its taste and the cause it supports, aiming to raise awareness for children's mental health through donations to On Our Sleeves.
Review topics: ["flavor","sunshine","ice cream","experience","pint"].
"Please consider bringing it back someday."
"it’s my favorite ice cream flavor of all time! i miss it so much :,("
"LOVED it was soooo good please bring back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
"Miss this flavor sooooo much."
"The greatest ice cream ever made. Please please please bring it back and make it permanent."
"Please please please bring it back!"
"It’s been all clouds and rain since Jeni’s Sunshine has been gone. We want to spread more kindness, and spend more dreamy days dripping cream on our sleeves. Bring out the Sunshine!"
"Hi Jeni, Pretty Please capital P would you bring back the sunshine flavor? My man will not stop talking about it and every time we go to the storefront he hounds the employees about Sunshine and they have had enough, please Jeni ~~ please consider this humble ask. Peace and love to you . Your work is Godly and we sing your praises ."
"Sunshine is easily one of the best flavors you’ve ever made, but I literally was able to buy 2 pints a few months ago & that was it. I never saw it available again. None of your stores in the DC area have ever offered it as far as I can tell either. It’s always sold out on the website too. For a newer flavor I just don’t get it. I know you recently released over 20 new flavors, & they seem to have taken the place of so many of your classics both in the Jeni’s store & in the grocery stores that carry Jeni’s. I’m almost shocked just how much I’m willing to spend to enjoy THE BEST ICE CREAM I’VE EVER HAD, & I lived in Italy for 2 years. Yes, it’s literally twice as much as ‘gourmet’ brands like Talenti & Haagen Daas, & 2.5x as much as Ben & Jerry’s - but while Talenti has some great flavors, I haven’t even considered buying any other ice cream since I first tried Jeni’s last year. I literally order 5-6 pints from your stores - usually via Uber Eats - every single week, in addition to ordering from the website & buying it at the grocery store. The new flavors are mind blowing, & I’m planning to review my favorite next, but first I’m reviewing my favorite flavors that I only found once or twice & that never seem to be in stock online or even available from your retail locations."
"This was an absolute favorite! Please bring it back. So special, nothing like it."