• Pint of Jeni's Watermelon Taffy ice cream, a red and white striped pint with a spoon topped with pink scoops
  • Close-up texture of Watermelon Taffy ice cream in bright pink

  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 105 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Watermelon Taffy offers a perfect puckery fruit flavor with a creamy, light texture, making it a favorite for tart candy lovers. Its delightful watermelon taste is complemented by a bouncy character from buttermilk and yogurt, ideal for enjoying on its own or as a float.

Summary topics

  • Creaminess (32%): Many customers expressed appreciation for the Watermelon Taffy flavor, stating it is their absolute favorite.
  • Fruit Flavor (56%): A substantial number of customers remarked that the flavor of the product is great and perfect for anytime of the year.
  • Watermelon Taffy Taste (20%): A significant amount of customers expressed appreciation for the watermelon taffy, describing it as perfect, DELISH, and their absolute favorite.

Review topics: ["flavor","texture","recipe","order","color","ice cream","watermelon taffy","watermelon","dream","tartness","jeni","cream","flavor of all time","summer","boston cream pie","words","hit","brew"].

Review highlights

  • "Extremely smooth and Creamy texture with an incredible Tart taste and finish." — Lawrence R.
  • "Watermelon Taffy is my absolute favorite flavor ice cream." — Rena F.
  • "Easily the best Jeni’s flavor (which is saying a lot), this may be my favorite ice cream flavor of all time, ever." — Aleta W.

Reviews

100/100

"This flavor is incredible, I have repurchased (locally) so many times and I’m dreading the end of summer in case it goes away! I’ll definitely order backups as that time nears."

— MG (5/5)

Great Ice Cream

"The ice cream is SO good. The coconut cream cold brew and Boston cream pie is DELICIOUS. I look forward to trying the maple soaked pancakes. Jenni’s ice cream is the bomb dot com!"

— Isaiah P. (5/5)

Amazing and tastes just like its name

"This is a new favorite for me and my husband. It’s SO good!! I love the tartness and the watermelon flavor. It really does taste like a watermelon laffy taffy!! It has a really lovely, smooth texture and the prettiest soft pink color. We have our freezer stocked up with several pints so we don’t have to share, lol! I love a spoonful after dinner. Please never stop making this flavor!!"

— jlhm (5/5)

Obsessed

"I love how it’s tart but the buttermilk makes it so creamy. New favorite ice cream for REAL. Please never get rid of this even though I know it’s just for the summer I’m begging you!!"

— Kelly (5/5)

LOVE

"Ice cream perfection! If this was available in the grocery store, I would purchase it regularly. Sweet and sour and just yum."

— Erin T. (5/5)

pucker up in the best way

"I adore Jeni's fruit based ice creams-- they are so tart yet so creamy and flavorful. Absolutely divine"

— KATHRYN W. (5/5)

RECIPE CHANGED

"The watermelon taffy that released in June 2026 is not the same as the prior recipes, so not sure why everything says “it’s back. ” We regularly purchased the Watermelon Taffy by the pint for years, every season, since it came out. Went to get 2 pints this week when we saw it was re-released only to notice it’s a new recipe. This current recipe is hard and doesn’t have the same smooth texture as previously. The texture is so different that it’s hard to compare the flavor. Incredibly disappointed. Could’ve at least mentioned it’s a new recipe. False advertising."

— Sierra (3/5)

Yum!

"Nailed it! Just like a beach boardwalk treat in the heart of summer. Love this"

— Todd W. (5/5)

Perfect summer flavor

"Love the watermelon taffy. Perfect"

— Kathleen L. (5/5)

Ice-cream Super heros

"Absolutely delectable everything is on point,tartness, smooth creamy, not to sweet, just right. . Ice-cream done right, life long fan, I discovered you at work, and placed my order as soon as I made it home, you're the Ice-cream super heros."

— Gregory R. (5/5)

Q&A