$19 Flat Rate Shipping

$9 Flat Rate Shipping

Products

Guaranteed frozen delivery.
Flat-rate shipping nationwide.
Instagram-worthy unboxing.
More filters
0 selected Reset
Clear all

88 products

Filter & sort

Filter & sort

88 products

More filters
Clear
Clear all
Clear all

88 products

  • Potluck Collection

    Pass the Jeni's.

    $68.00

  • Powdered Jelly Donut

    Vanilla custard, raspberry jelly, and a brown sugar donut crumble.

    $14.00

  • Punk Stargonaut Collection

    Flavors from a distant galaxy.

    $68.00

  • Purple Star Born

    Reminiscent of Concord grape and puckery-like blackcurrants. Intensely juicy!

    $14.00

  • Ice cream in the mail? Yes, this is real life.

    • Guaranteed frozen delivery. Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

    • Flat-rate shipping nationwide. No matter how many pints you order.

    • Instagram-worthy unboxing. Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

  • Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks

    Salted and roasted ground peanuts with grass-grazed milk and crunchy, dark chocolate flecks.

    $14.00

  • Salty Caramel

    Fire-toasted sugar with sea salt, vanilla, and grass-grazed milk. A perfect balance of salty and sweet.

    $14.00

  • Salty Caramel Party Pack (12-count)

    Give your next event a salty-sweet flourish.

    $36.00

  • Savannah Buttermint

    A buttery after dinner mint ice cream with white chocolate flecks.

    $14.00

  • Skillet Cinnamon Roll

    Dark caramel, cream cheese, pastry, and cinnamon (lots of it).

    $14.00

  • Snow Cone Sorbet

    A far-out twist of blue brambleberry, watermelon, and pink lemonade sorbets.

    $14.00

  • Strawberry Buttermilk

    Grown-for-us Ohio strawberries blended with cream and cultured buttermilk for subtle tartness.

    $14.00

  • Sunshine

    Sun-kissed lemon and sweet-tart tangerine with radiant passion fruit. Tastes like sunshine on a cloudy day.

    $14.00

  • Super Fun Times! T-Shirt

    New!! Summer!!! Merch!!!!

    $21.00

  • Supermoon

    Tastes like candied violet and marshmallows. Almost like cereal milk!

    $14.00

  • Sweet Cream Biscuits & Peach Jam

    Buttermilk ice cream, crumbled biscuits, and swirls of peach jam.

    $14.00

  • Sympathy Collection

    Send love and comfort.

    $68.00