Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.
Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.
Overall rating: 4.5454545 / 5 from 22 reviews.
Toasted S'mores offers a delightful blend of toasty, candy-like vanilla ice cream, lightly caramelized marshmallow, and deeply milky chocolate sauce, reminiscent of a classic campfire treat. While some customers find the flavor too light or too strong, others praise the ice cream as phenomenal and a great gift idea.
Review topics: ["flavor","gift","chocolate","ice cream","balance","pint"].
"Sent jeni’s to friends that are recuperating from health issues. Brought such smiles to their faces- they called so excited. They loved each and every flavor of the 6 pints sent! Great great gift for those that are ice cream lovers, and who isn’t! I was so happy for the free shipping! Such a plus."
"When my dad received the order on the day before Father's Day, the entire order was melted and was "soup", with no dry ice in the package at all. However, when I contacted customer service, they were quick to offer a refund or replacement. They sent a replacement order within a few days and it was perfect, and my dad loved it. Our previous order had been perfect, the ice cream is delicious, (as reported by my dad) and customer service was top notch. This is a great gift idea for the person who loves ice cream and no longer needs new shirts, or socks."
"I’m so sad I didn’t get any of this one. My son ate the entire container in one sitting. He said it was absolutely the best he’s ever had. I’m going to order another now."
"This is a really good ice cream: a good balance of marshmallow, chocolate and graham crumbles which don't overwhelm anything. For me, the smoky flavor is just a little too strong, almost comes across as coffee flavor which isn't in a store."
"Good flavor but needs a bit more chocolate. There is never enough chocolate right?"
"I found it a little Smokey tasting, but my kids tore right in. That pint was gone before we knew it."
"I’m sorry but I definitely did not get a root beer float flavor profile. The flavors were too light. I would expected a thick root beer swirl."
"Delicious deconstructed s’mores with little bites of graham crackers, swirls of decadent dark chocolate syrup within a smokey vanilla bean marshmallow ice cream!"
"I really really enjoyed this flavor and gobbled it quickly however I wish there was more marshmallow flavor! I didn’t taste it at all in the ice cream- just vanilla."
"The best summer flavor of 2025 thus far but still left something to be desired. I craved a caramel to be added to this one. Wasn't terrible, but I won't be repurchasing."
Guaranteed frozen delivery. Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.
Free shipping in the contiguous U.S. No matter how many pints you order.
Instagram-worthy unboxing. Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.
LOCAL DELIVERY
SCOOP SHOPS
GROCERY LOCATOR