Skip to content

NEW! Summer flavors just dropped. 

Skip to product information
  • Guaranteed frozen delivery

    Pints arrive in an insulated box with plenty of dry ice.

  • Nationwide delivery

    We ship to all 50 United States and the District of Columbia.

  • Instagram-worthy unboxing

    Pints are packaged with an artful attention to detail.

Overall rating: 4.9130435 / 5 from 23 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Summary topics

Review topics: ["flavor","ice cream","jeni","pretzels","flavor profile"].

Review highlights

Reviews

Divine!

"Holy moly. This was not the summer flavor I was most excited about but it should have been. The only thing I would change is to turn the sweetness down a small notch (the strawberry adds a lot of sweetness!). Otherwise, this is easily my new favorite flavor! The pretzel streusel is salty and crunchy enough and the cheesecake ice cream base balances it all. I mean, just the most divine ice cream for summer that I hope makes it into the year-round selection!"

Paige (5/5)

Disappointing

"I wish i can say the verdict was amazing as Strawberry Pretzel Pie is one of my absolute favorite Jenis flavors. However, the verdict unfortunately is disappointing. I placed my last order because of this flavor including 3 pints of this delicious flavor and 4 pints of other flavors I enjoy. When the order got delivered all 7 pints arrived warm and completely in liquid form and by the time Jenis contacted me to make it right this flavor was out of stock."

Lisa B. (5/5)

Bring It Back, And No One Will Get Hurt…

"I am obsessed with this flavor. Like, stalked for a year until it came back, obsessed. Researched recipes online after it sold out, obsessed. Also researched the best ice cream makers, obsessed. Please don’t make me do this. All I want to do is order multiple pints to hoard in my freezer and eat them while wrapped in a blanket, shielded from the stares of others, like the sugar-dopamine gremlin I am. Don’t you judge me! Feed me more of this and tell me I’m pretty…"

Revonna J. (5/5)

Pot luck fave but better

"If you’ve ever had this summer pot luck fave, you know just how good it is! This ice cream tastes identical to that summer treat. The strawberries are real, the “pretzels” don’t get soggy, this quickly moved to the top."

Heather R. (5/5)

I need more!

"So so good! The pretzel is perfectly crunchy and salty and goes well with the sweet strawberry jam and creamy ice cream. My new favorite, I hope they bring it back! 10 out of 10!!!"

Kristen S. (5/5)

Divine

"The multiple flavors come in waves. The creamy coolness makes all the merciless heat and humidity of this summer melt away. A delicious and deserved treat, indeed!"

Sue F. (5/5)

excellent

"A perfect flavor match for my grandma's recipe. I love the sweet cream base and pretzel swirls"

Steph B. (5/5)

Need to put this on permanently

"I have never had a bad Jeni’s ice cream - some are just off the chart stand puts and this strawberry Pretzel Pie was one of those - wish I had ordered more as I don’t see it as an option anymore - please bring it back!"

Sherri M. (5/5)

I've been searching for this pretzel crumble!

"So, tbh, there was a hint of strawberry once or twice, but that pretzel crumble is what I've been searching for!! Make more ice creams w pretzel salt in it!!! Stg, it's been a quest for over a decade!"

Katie M. (5/5)

Best flavor made!!!

"It’s the best flavor profile available!!! Please make it a full time flavor or release more when it is released."

Betsy M. (5/5)

Q&A